
Swarnlata Mishra
The girl who sang a foreign song · ur. 1948
A three-year-old, travelling through the town of Katni, asked her father to turn "to her house". Later she recognised people even though attempts were made to mislead her.
Investigated case: researchers checked the facts and witnesses; some of it fits, but the explanation remains disputed.
The tale
Swarnlata Mishra was born in 1948 in central India. When she was three, she was passing through the town of Katni with her father and suddenly asked to go down a road "to her house". She said her name had been Biya Pathak and that she had two sons.
Biya Pathak really did live in Katni and died in 1939. When her relatives came to the Mishras in 1959, Swarnlata reportedly recognised them one by one and called them by name. One of the "sons" tried to convince her that she was someone else, but she did not give in.
What was checked
The case was investigated by the Indian parapsychologist H. N. Banerjee and by Ian Stevenson, who talked with both families. Swarnlata also sang songs in Bengali, a language not known in her home.
What the critics say
Critics point out that there was a good deal of contact between the families before the researchers wrote down the accounts. The child may also have heard the Bengali songs somewhere, and Stevenson himself admitted that he did not know where they came from.
Other stories
Shanti DeviThe girl who returned to Mathura
James LeiningerThe little pilot from Louisiana
Ryan HammonsThe boy who remembered Hollywood
The Pollock twinsThe sisters who came back to Hexham
Omm SetyThe Englishwoman who returned to Abydos
Imad ElawarThe boy from a Druze village
Cameron MacaulayThe boy from Glasgow and the island of Barra
Finding the Dalai LamaHow the 14th Dalai Lama was sought
Bridey MurphyThe Irishwoman who never existed
General George PattonA soldier of many wars
Henry FordThe carmaker who believed in many lives
Juliusz SłowackiThe Polish bard and the wandering of the spirit
Pythagoras and the puppyThe philosopher who recognised a friend's voice
Edgar CayceThe sleeping prophet from KentuckySources
- I. Stevenson, Twenty Cases Suggestive of Reincarnation, 1966