
Reincarnation
Do we live more than once?
Do we live only once? For three thousand years, people all over the world have said that the soul returns. Hindus and Buddhists believe it, and so did Pythagoras and Plato, the druids, the kabbalists, Juliusz Słowacki and Henry Ford. In the 20th century, the psychiatrist Ian Stevenson began recording the accounts of children who talk about a "previous life". Here we have gathered the most famous stories, what was checked in them, and what the critics say.
In numbers
- ok. 26% of Poles say they believe in reincarnation (CBOS, 2012)
- 33% of American adults believe in reincarnation (Pew Research Center, 2018)
- ponad 2500 child cases in the University of Virginia archive (Division of Perceptual Studies)
- 2–7 lat the age at which children usually talk about a "previous life" (I. Stevenson, J. Tucker)
People's stories
Shanti DeviIndia · 1926–1987
James LeiningerUSA · ur. 1998
Ryan HammonsUSA · ur. 2004
The Pollock twinsEngland · ur. 1958
Omm SetyEngland and Egypt · 1904–1981
Imad ElawarLebanon · ur. 1958
Swarnlata MishraIndia · ur. 1948
Cameron MacaulayScotland · ur. ok. 2000
Finding the Dalai LamaTibet · 1933–1940
Bridey MurphyUSA · 1952–1956
General George PattonUSA · 1885–1945
Henry FordUSA · 1863–1947
Juliusz SłowackiPoland · 1809–1849
Pythagoras and the puppyGreece · VI w. p.n.e.
Edgar CayceUSA · 1877–1945The wandering of ideas across the world
India: the wheel of samsara (from c. 8th–6th century BCE)
The oldest reliable texts about the wandering of the soul are the Indian Upanishads. They teach that the true "self", the atman, does not die with the body but passes into a new one. Which body it is reborn into depends on karma, that is, the consequences of past deeds.
This cycle of birth and death is called samsara. The goal is not to come back for as long as possible, but to be freed from the wheel. Hindus call this liberation moksha. The same idea, each in its own way, was taken up by Jainism and Sikhism.
„As a person casts off worn-out clothes and puts on new ones, so the soul abandons worn-out bodies and enters new ones.”
Bhagawadgita 2,22
The Buddha and Tibet (od V w. p.n.e.)
The Buddha adopted the Indian idea of rebirth, but changed it. He taught that there is no permanent, unchanging soul that jumps from body to body. What is reborn is rather a stream of causes and effects, like a flame passed from one candle to another.
The texts say that on the night of his awakening the Buddha remembered many of his past lives. The Tibetans developed the teaching of the bardo, the state between death and a new birth, which is said to last up to forty-nine days. From this came the so-called Tibetan Book of the Dead, read beside the deceased. The tradition of the tulku also comes from Tibet, that is, the recognition of teachers who have been reborn. The most famous of them is the Dalai Lama.
„The beginning of this wandering cannot be discovered. No first point can be seen from which beings, shrouded in ignorance, wander and circle.”
Samyutta Nikaya 15,3 (free translation)
Egypt: a myth that was not Egyptian (Herodot, V w. p.n.e.)
The Greek historian Herodotus wrote that the Egyptians were the first to teach that after death the soul enters one animal after another and, after three thousand years, returns to a human body.
Egyptologists today say bluntly that this is a mistake. The Egyptians believed in life after death, in the judgement of Osiris, and in the idea that the ba soul can take on different forms, but not in successive earthly incarnations. Herodotus most likely attributed to them the beliefs of his own countrymen, the Pythagoreans.
„The Egyptians were the first to proclaim that the human soul is immortal and that when the body dies, it enters another creature that happens to be born at that moment.”
Herodotus, Histories II, 123
Greece: Pythagoras and Plato (6th–4th century BCE)
In Greece the wandering of souls was called metempsychosis. It was taught by the Orphics and by Pythagoras, who reportedly remembered his past incarnations and for that reason did not eat meat.
Plato described it most beautifully. In the "Republic" he tells the myth of Er, a soldier who fell in battle and came back to life on the funeral pyre after twelve days. Er saw how souls choose their next life for themselves. Orpheus chose the life of a swan, Ajax that of a lion, and Odysseus, weary of fame, the quiet life of an ordinary man. Then the souls drank water from the river of Forgetfulness and forgot everything. Plato also believed that learning is, at bottom, recalling what the soul already knew.
„It is not a god who will choose you, but you yourselves will choose your fate. The blame lies with the one who chooses; the god is blameless.”
Plato, Republic X, 617e
The druids and the Celts (I w. p.n.e.)
Julius Caesar, who was conquering Gaul, wrote that the druids teach that souls do not perish but pass after death into other bodies. He thought this was why Celtic warriors did not fear death.
This is a hostile account, written by a Roman, and the druids themselves wrote nothing down. Historians debate whether Caesar understood them correctly or fitted their teaching to the ideas of Pythagoras that he knew.
„Above all they want to convince people that souls do not die, but pass after death from one body into another. They believe this stirs courage most, because the fear of death disappears.”
Julius Caesar, The Gallic War VI, 14
The Slavs: traces and guesses (before the 10th century and in folk memory)
The ancient Slavs left no writings of their own, so we do not know for sure whether they believed in the return of the soul. We only have traces. Children were given the names of dead grandparents, and at Dziady food, warmth and an open door were prepared for the souls of ancestors. Some ethnologists see in this a belief that an ancestor can return within the family.
That is, however, a hypothesis, not a certainty. Such customs may just as well simply express remembrance of the dead and the belief that souls visit the home. In honesty it must be said that many modern tales of "Slavic reincarnation" are embellishments without sources.
„Dark everywhere, silent everywhere, what will it be, what will it be?”
Adam Mickiewicz, Dziady Part II, the rite of summoning the souls
Kabbalah: gilgul (from the 12th century, flourishing in the 16th century)
In Jewish mysticism the wandering of the soul is called gilgul, meaning "rolling". It is mentioned in the Zohar and was developed by the great kabbalist Isaac Luria of Safed. His disciple Chaim Vital wrote down this teaching in the "Gate of Reincarnations".
According to the Kabbalah the soul returns to repair what it did not manage to, and to complete its task. This process of repair is called tikkun. The idea of gilgul was also taken up by the Hasidim, including in the Polish lands, and it appears in their stories to this day.
„The soul may return many times, until it has fulfilled all the commandments and repaired what it spoiled.”
a thought from Chaim Vital's "Gate of Reincarnations" (summary)
Christianity: a dispute from centuries ago (3rd–13th century)
The theologian Origen of Alexandria taught in the 3rd century that souls existed before they were born. That was not yet reincarnation, but a thought close to it. In the 6th century the views of his followers were condemned, and the Church held that a person lives on earth once, and then comes judgement.
In the Middle Ages belief in the wandering of souls was held by the Cathars in southern France, who were declared heretics. The present teaching of the Catholic Church says clearly that there is no reincarnation. Even so, as surveys show, some Polish Catholics believe in it.
„It is appointed for people to die once, and after that comes judgement.”
Letter to the Hebrews 9:27
Islam and the Druze (from the 11th century)
Most Muslims reject reincarnation, because the Quran speaks of one life and of resurrection. The exception is the Druze of Lebanon, Syria and Israel. They believe the soul is reborn immediately after death in a newborn child.
That is why in Druze villages children who talk about a previous life are taken completely seriously. It was there that Ian Stevenson found one of his most famous cases, a boy named Imad.
„To die is like changing a shirt.”
a vivid Druze expression ("changing a shirt")
Africa, the Arctic, America (traditions alive to this day)
Among the Yoruba in Nigeria a boy may be given the name Babatunde, meaning "the father has returned", and a girl Yetunde, "the mother has returned". The Inuit believe that with the name of the deceased, part of their soul passes to the child.
The Tlingit of Alaska told that before dying they announced to which relative they would return, and pointed to birthmarks by which they were to be recognised. Stevenson studied such cases in Alaska in the 1960s.
„Babatunde: the father has returned.”
a name in the Yoruba language
The West discovers reincarnation (19th–21st century)
In the West the idea of reincarnation was popularised in the 19th century by the Theosophists, above all Helena Blavatsky, and later by Rudolf Steiner. In Poland, Juliusz Słowacki wrote about the wandering of the spirit.
In the 20th century the subject made its way into books on hypnotic regression, into cinema and into scientific research. Today, according to polls, one in three Americans and one in four Poles believe in reincarnation, often alongside Christian faith.
„I adopted the theory of reincarnation when I was twenty-six. Work would be futile if we could not use the experience of one life in the next.”
Henry Ford, San Francisco Examiner, 1928
What has been studied
Ian Stevenson was a respected psychiatrist, head of the psychiatric clinic at the University of Virginia. In 1961 he went to India to check the accounts of children who spoke about a previous life, and he worked on this until his death in 2007. He travelled to India, Sri Lanka, Lebanon, Turkey, Burma, Alaska and Europe. His work is continued by the psychiatrist Jim Tucker.
Stevenson never claimed to have proved reincarnation. He gave his first book a cautious title: “Twenty Cases Suggestive of Reincarnation.” He looked for other explanations, such as fraud, chance or overheard conversations, and described when none of them fitted.
What recurs in children's cases
Age. Children usually start talking about a previous life between the ages of two and four, and stop around the age of six or seven.
Violent death. In the archive of the University of Virginia, about seven in ten of the described “previous persons” died suddenly: in an accident, in war or as a result of violence.
A short interval. Between the death of the “previous person” and the birth of the child, usually about a year and a half passed.
Stigmas. Stevenson described more than two hundred cases in which a child's birthmark or birth defect was said to correspond to a wound of the deceased. He collected them in the two-volume work “Reincarnation and Biology” of 1997.
Fears and play. Children are often afraid of what was said to have killed the previous person, for example water or cars, and act out that person's profession in play.
What the critics say
Culture. Most cases occur where people believe in reincarnation. A family that believes in it more easily matches a child's words to some deceased person.
Adults' memory. The child's words were rarely written down before the families met. Witnesses' memories, years later, mix with what they learned afterwards.
Cryptomnesia. The child may have heard something on television or from adults and forgotten where they know it from. The classic example is the Bridey Murphy case.
No mechanism. Science knows of no way in which memories could survive without a brain and pass into another body. In his 1996 book “Reincarnation: A Critical Examination,” the philosopher Paul Edwards collected the strongest objections.
„There are three claims in this field that, in my opinion, deserve serious investigation. The third of them: that small children sometimes give details of a previous life that, once checked, turn out to be accurate, and that they could not have learned other than through reincarnation.”
Carl Sagan, astronomer and sceptic, The Demon-Haunted World, 1995. He added that he chose them not because he considers them true.
How could it work?
Nobody knows how reincarnation would work, if it exists at all. Here are the most important ideas, from religious to scientific. All but the last are unconfirmed hypotheses.
A soul outside the body (hipoteza). The oldest answer: a human being has an immortal soul, and the body is its clothing. This is what Plato, Hindus and many mystics thought. Science can neither prove nor rule it out.
The brain as a radio (hipoteza). In 1898 the psychologist William James asked whether the brain really produces consciousness. Perhaps it only receives and transmits it, like a radio a signal. When the radio breaks, the broadcast goes on. Jim Tucker and some near-death researchers refer to this idea today.
A stream without a soul (hipoteza). Buddhists hold that no permanent “self” passes on, only a chain of causes and effects, karma. Like a flame jumping from candle to candle: it is not the same, but it is not entirely different either.
DMT as a gateway (hipoteza). Rick Strassman supposed that at the moment of birth and death the brain releases DMT, and that this opens a state in which consciousness leaves the body or enters it. There is no evidence in humans.
Memory in a field (hipoteza). The biologist Rupert Sheldrake claims that memories are not stored in the brain, but in “fields” to which the brain connects. A child could then “tune in” to the memory of someone deceased. Most scientists reject this theory.
The psychological explanation. The view of most scientists: memories live in the brain and perish with it. Children's accounts can be explained by imagination, overheard conversations, unconscious cues from adults and chance hits.
Books people talk about
The wandering of souls
Michael Newton, 1994 (Journey of Souls)
An American hypnotherapist described sessions in which people in deep hypnosis spoke not about previous lives but about the time between them. According to these accounts, after death the soul leaves the body, meets a guide, returns to its “soul group,” stands before a council of elders and itself chooses its next life and body. Newton claimed that the descriptions of thousands of clients were surprisingly consistent. The sequel is “Destiny of Souls.”
What research says: Accounts from hypnosis cannot be verified. The consistency of the stories may result from how the hypnotist conducted the sessions and what questions he asked.
DMT. The Spirit Molecule
Rick Strassman, 2000 (DMT: The Spirit Molecule)
A psychiatrist from the University of New Mexico conducted, in 1990–1995, the first studies in twenty years approved in the USA on a psychedelic substance, DMT. Volunteers described experiences similar to a near-death experience: a tunnel, a light, encounters with beings. Strassman put forward a bold hypothesis that the pineal gland in the brain may release DMT at the moment of birth and death, as if opening a door of the soul. He also noted that the pineal gland becomes visible in the embryo at around the forty-ninth day, and that is exactly how long, according to the Tibetans, the soul's journey through the bardo lasts.
What research says: The author himself called it speculation. In 2019 scientists detected DMT in rat brains, and its level rose after cardiac arrest. In humans there is no proof that the pineal gland produces it in an amount that could cause such experiences. DMT is illegal in Poland and we do not encourage any attempts.
Many Lives, Many Masters
Brian Weiss, 1988 (Many Lives, Many Masters)
A psychiatrist from Miami described a patient, Catherine, who under hypnosis was said to recall dozens of past lives, from ancient Egypt to the 20th century. Her fears were said to weaken as she discovered their “source” in previous incarnations. Between lives she passed on the words of “masters,” spiritual teachers. The book sold millions of copies and popularised regression.
What research says: Nobody has independently verified Catherine's lives. Psychologists remind us that under hypnosis convincing but false memories easily arise.
Twenty Cases Suggestive of Reincarnation
Ian Stevenson, 1966 (Twenty Cases Suggestive of Reincarnation)
The most important research book in this field. Stevenson describes children from India, Sri Lanka, Brazil, Alaska and Lebanon, including Imad Elawar and Swarnlata Mishra. For each case he lists what the child said, what he checked and what the other possible explanations are.
What research says: Written cautiously, in scientific language. Even critics admit that Stevenson was meticulous, although they disagree with his conclusions.
Life Before Life
Jim B. Tucker, 2005 (Life Before Life)
Stevenson's successor at the University of Virginia sums up forty years of research on children. In his second book, “Return to Life” of 2013, he describes American cases, including James Leininger and Ryan Hammons, and proposes his own hypothesis: that consciousness may be something fundamental, not a product of the brain.
What research says: This is a philosophical hypothesis, not the result of an experiment. Tucker himself writes about the weaknesses of the cases.
Life After Life
Raymond Moody, 1975 (Life After Life)
A physician collected accounts from people who survived clinical death. He popularised the term “near-death experience”: leaving the body, a tunnel, a light, meeting deceased loved ones and a life review. The book does not speak directly about reincarnation, but it opened up in the West the question of what happens to consciousness at the moment of death.
What research says: The experiences themselves are well documented and are still studied today. The dispute is over whether they are evidence of life after death or a reaction of a dying brain.
The Tibetan Book of the Dead
Tibetan tradition, 14th c., translation 1927 (Bardo Thödol)
A text read to the deceased for forty-nine days. It guides them through the bardo: first the clear light, then gentle and fearsome visions, up to the choice of a new womb. It teaches that all these images are a projection of the mind and that recognising this brings liberation. It reached the West in 1927 thanks to Evans-Wentz's translation, and was read, among others, by Carl Gustav Jung.
What research says: It is a religious text, not an account that can be checked. Its images surprisingly resemble the descriptions in the books of Moody and Strassman.
Hypnotic regression: a warning
Hypnotic regression consists of a hypnotist leading a person “backwards,” to childhood and then to alleged previous lives. The books of the American psychiatrist Brian Weiss became famous, for example “Many Lives, Many Masters” of 1988.
The research by psychologists is unambiguous here, however. The Canadian psychologist Nicholas Spanos showed in the 1990s that “previous lives” told under hypnosis adjust to what the hypnotist suggested before the session. Hypnosis does not improve memory, but it does increase confidence in false memories. People in regression often confuse historical facts, and a surprising number of them “were” Cleopatra or a knight.
That is why regression is an interesting experience and can be a source of self-insight, but it is not proof of reincarnation. If someone goes through difficult emotions, it is better to seek help from a qualified psychologist or psychotherapist.
Curiosities
Where the word comes from. “Reincarnation” comes from Latin and means “re-embodiment,” literally “entering a body again.” The Greeks said metempsychosis, meaning “the passing of the soul.”
China and official incarnations. In 2007 the Chinese religious affairs authority issued regulations under which recognising a reborn Tibetan lama requires the approval of the state.
The River of Forgetfulness. In Plato, souls drink water from the River of Forgetfulness before a new life. That is why we still speak of “sinking into oblivion,” and the Greeks called this river Lethe.
Forty-nine days. In the Tibetan tradition the deceased passes through the bardo for up to forty-nine days. During that time the family prays and reads texts to them.
The Dalai Lama announces. In July 2025 the 14th Dalai Lama announced that after his death the institution of the Dalai Lama will continue, and that his successor will be named by his own foundation.
Tlingit birthmarks. Before death, the Tlingit of Alaska showed relatives marks by which they were to be recognised in a new child. Stevenson described several such cases.
We do not settle whether reincarnation exists. Science has neither confirmed nor ruled it out, and honest researchers on both sides speak of "suggestive cases", not of proof. With each story we separate what can be checked in documents from accounts and from legend. We write with respect for believers and non-believers alike.
Frequently asked questions
Is reincarnation proven?
No. There are cases that researchers call “suggestive of reincarnation,” but none is proof that would convince science. Nor is there proof that reincarnation does not exist.
Who has studied reincarnation scientifically?
The best known is the psychiatrist Ian Stevenson of the University of Virginia, who from 1961 to 2007 collected accounts from children around the world. His work is continued by Jim Tucker, and in Iceland Erlendur Haraldsson studied it.
How many Poles believe in reincarnation?
According to a 2012 CBOS poll, about a quarter of Poles, often alongside Christian faith.
Which religions believe in reincarnation?
Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism, Sikhism, the Druze, some currents of Kabbalah and many traditional peoples. Pythagoras, Plato and, according to Caesar, the druids also believed in it.
Does hypnotic regression reveal past lives?
Studies show that under hypnosis false memories easily arise that seem very real. The most famous example is the Bridey Murphy case, explained by cryptomnesia.
At what age do children talk about a previous life?
They usually begin between the ages of two and four, and around six or seven they stop and often forget.
Sources
- Division of Perceptual Studies, University of Virginia
- Psi Encyclopedia, Society for Psychical Research
- Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: Reincarnation
- Pew Research Center, 2018: Beliefs about the afterlife
- CBOS, Wiara i religijność Polaków, 2012
- Wolne Lektury: Platon, Mickiewicz, Słowacki