Enter the forest
Mystic and science

Sound

Sound is the trembling of the world. It moves water, sand and human hearts. Here we separate what has been measured from what people want to believe.

Open Sound in the applisten and watch the waves live

Sound is a wave

Sound is a wave: particles of air, water or rock push their neighbours, and those push the next ones. Nothing flies from the guitar to the ear; only the trembling travels.

A hertz is one vibration per second

Measured and confirmed

Frequency determines the pitch of a tone. A 440 Hz sound is 440 vibrations per second, the note A4, to which orchestras tune. Humans hear roughly from 20 Hz to 20,000 Hz, and the upper limit drops with age.

Infrasound: too low for the ear

Measured and confirmed

Elephants call to each other below 20 Hz, even over several kilometres, and such waves are recorded by barographs. The 1883 eruption of Krakatau sent out a pressure wave that instruments around the world recorded several times as it circled the Earth.

Ultrasound: too high for the ear

Measured and confirmed

Above 20,000 Hz bats cry out. From the echo they know where a moth is flying. A doctor does the same during an ultrasound scan, only with a wave whose frequency is millions of hertz.

Decibels and your hearing

Measured and confirmed

The decibel scale is logarithmic: +10 dB is 10 times more energy, and to the ear roughly twice as loud. Listening for hours to sounds above 85 dB (a busy street, a lawn mower) can permanently damage hearing cells, which do not regenerate.

Timbre: why a violin is not a flute

Measured and confirmed

The same note from different instruments sounds different because, besides the fundamental frequency, its multiples also vibrate, that is, the overtones. Their proportions are the instrument's "fingerprint".

Music and harmony

Music is sound arranged in proportions and rhythm. The brain rewards it the way it rewards food. Quite a few myths have grown up around music, however.

Pythagoras and simple proportions

Measured and confirmed

A string shortened by half sounds an octave higher, and shortened to 2/3 it gives a fifth. Sounds with simple frequency ratios sound harmonious to most people. This is one of the oldest discoveries of physics.

Hammers in the smithy

Legend, theory or pseudoscience

Legend has it that Pythagoras discovered harmony by hearing blacksmiths' hammers weighing 12, 9, 8 and 6. A nice story, but physically untrue: the pitch of a hammer does not depend on its weight in such a simple way.

Chills from music

Measured and confirmed

When a favourite song reaches its peak, the brain releases dopamine, the same reward signal as when eating. This was shown in PET scans (positron emission tomography) in 2011. That is why music can literally send shivers down your spine.

Music therapy

Measured and confirmed

Cochrane reviews show that music reduces anxiety before a procedure, and music therapy led by a therapist helps with depression, as an addition to treatment. The effects are moderate, but real. It does not replace treatment.

The Mozart effect

Legend, theory or pseudoscience

In 1993, students after 10 minutes of Mozart did better on one spatial task, for a dozen or so minutes. The media turned this into "Mozart raises children's IQ". Large analyses have not confirmed a lasting effect.

The magical 432 Hz

Legend, theory or pseudoscience

The internet claims that 432 Hz tuning is the "frequency of the universe" and that 440 Hz was imposed to make us anxious. There is no evidence for this. The standard A4 = 440 Hz was adopted so that orchestras around the world could play together, and it made it into the ISO 16 standard. Studies of 432 Hz are isolated small trials.

"Solfeggio frequencies" and 528 Hz

Legend, theory or pseudoscience

Popular recordings promise that 528 Hz "repairs DNA". These numbers come from books of the 1970s and 1990s, not from ancient chant. No reliable study has shown healing with sound of a specific frequency.

Binaural beats

There is research, but results are uncertain

When one ear hears 400 Hz and the other 410 Hz, the brain "hears" a 10 Hz pulsation. The phenomenon itself is real, described in 1839. Does it improve sleep, focus or mood? Study results are mixed and very varied.

Sound and water

Water and sand show sound to the eyes. All you need is a plate, a bow and a handful of sand to turn trembling into a mandala.

Chladni figures

Measured and confirmed

In 1787 Ernst Chladni sprinkled sand on a metal plate and rubbed its edge with a bow. The sand fled from the places that vibrated and settled on the lines of stillness, the nodes. Each tone gives a different pattern. After Chladni's demonstration in Paris in 1808, Napoleon funded a prize for a mathematical explanation of these figures.

Faraday waves

Measured and confirmed

In 1831 Michael Faraday set a vessel of liquid vibrating. Standing patterns appeared on the surface: squares, hexagons, flowers. Coffee in a cup on a washing machine trembles in the same way.

Cymatics

There is research, but results are uncertain

The name was coined in 1967 by Hans Jenny, who photographed sound patterns in fluids and powders. The patterns are real and beautiful. Claims that such patterns heal or "put in order" the water in the body have no evidence.

Light from a bubble

Measured and confirmed

Strong ultrasound in water creates a bubble that collapses so violently that it flashes with light. This is sonoluminescence, discovered in 1934. For a fraction of a second the temperature inside the bubble is thousands of degrees.

The shrimp that shoots

Measured and confirmed

The pistol shrimp snaps its claw shut so fast that it fires a jet of water and a cavitation bubble. The bubble bursts with a bang reaching about 190 dB (these are decibels measured in water, counted differently than in air), stuns a small fish and glows for a moment.

Whale songs

Measured and confirmed

Humpback whales sing long, repeated songs that change from year to year like hit songs. They were described in 1971. Sound travels so well in water that the low calls of fin whales can be heard hundreds of kilometres away.

Masaru Emoto's water crystals

Legend, theory or pseudoscience

Emoto showed photographs: water "after Mozart" forms beautiful ice crystals, and "after the word anger" ugly ones. He chose the photographs himself, knowing which sample was which. No one has repeated this in a fair, blind study.

Water memory

Legend, theory or pseudoscience

In 1988 Jacques Benveniste announced in Nature that water "remembers" a substance dissolved in it. A check carried out with the editors of Nature did not confirm the results in blinded trials. Supporters of homeopathy use it to explain how homeopathy works.

Levitation and pyramids

Sound really can lift an object. Only a very small one. And the pyramids were built by people: their diaries, ramps and paintings have survived.

Acoustic levitation exists

Measured and confirmed

Two ultrasonic waves travelling toward each other create a standing wave. In its nodes the sound pressure holds a drop of water or a polystyrene bead in the air. In the laboratory even an ant, a ladybird and a small fish have been lifted this way.

Tweezers made of sound

Measured and confirmed

In 2015 scientists from Bristol and Sussex built an "acoustic hologram": 64 small loudspeakers move and rotate a levitated bead like invisible fingers. Today droplets of medicine and cells are moved this way.

Why you cannot lift a boulder

Measured and confirmed

A levitated object must be smaller than the wavelength and very light. To lift a stone weighing a tonne with sound, the pressure of the wave would have to be so enormous that the sound would heat the air and shatter the stone itself before lifting it.

Monks with horns in Tibet

Legend, theory or pseudoscience

The Swedish engineer Henry Kjellson described in 1961 a story told by an acquaintance: monks were supposed to lift boulders onto a cliff by the sound of horns and drums. There are no witnesses, photographs or location. Since then the story has circulated in books about "lost technology".

The Arab legend of the magic papyrus

Legend, theory or pseudoscience

Medieval Arabic tales, attributed among others to al-Masudi, said that the builders placed a papyrus with a spell under a stone, struck it with a rod, and the stone moved by itself the distance of a bowshot. This is a fairy tale, not an eyewitness account: it was written down more than three thousand years after the construction.

Coral Castle

Legend, theory or pseudoscience

Edward Leedskalnin built a castle by himself in Florida (1923–1951) from limestone blocks weighing as much as over 20 tonnes. He claimed to know "the secret of the pyramids". He worked at night, but photographs of his tripods, blocks and winches survive. Patience and levers were enough.

Merer's diary ok. 2560 p.n.e.

The oldest known papyri in the world, found in 2013 at Wadi al-Jarf. The inspector Merer recorded in them how his men floated blocks of limestone by boat from Tura to Giza for the construction of the pyramid of Khufu.

The lost arm of the Nile odkrycie 2024

Satellite images and boreholes revealed an ancient, dried-up arm of the Nile running right beside 31 pyramids. The stone floated by water almost to the construction site.

Sledges and wet sand badanie 2014

In the tomb of Djehutihotep, 172 men are painted pulling a statue on a sledge. One pours water onto the sand in front of the runners. Physicists from Amsterdam checked: well-wetted sand reduces friction by roughly half.

The Hatnub ramp odkrycie 2018

In an ancient alabaster quarry a steep ramp with steps and post holes was found. Ropes were threaded around the posts as if around pulleys, to haul blocks uphill.

The builders' village excavations since 1988

Bakeries, breweries and workers' graves were uncovered near Giza. They ate beef, were treated for fractures and were buried with honours beside the pyramids. They were not slaves under the lash, but paid crews.

Sacred places of sound

People have always built places where the voice sounds different. Did they do it on purpose? Acousticians measure, archaeologists argue.

Bells against storms

Measured and confirmed

Bells were inscribed "fulgura frango", that is "I break the lightning", and were rung during a storm. The result was the opposite: according to a German book of 1784, in 33 years lightning struck 386 towers, killing 103 bell-ringers. Today we have lightning rods.

Singing bowls

There is research, but results are uncertain

A bowl rubbed with a mallet sings a long tone full of overtones. Their ritual use in old Tibet is poorly documented; as "Tibetan meditation bowls" they became fashionable in the West in the 20th century. Studies of relaxation after bowls are small and without control groups.

The shaman's drum

There is research, but results are uncertain

Siberian shamans and the Sami put themselves into trance with the rhythm of a drum, often 4–7 beats per second. The claim that such a rhythm "retunes" brain waves comes from a single study of 1962 and has no strong evidence. What is certain is that rhythm sweeps the body into movement.

Mantra and humming

There is research, but results are uncertain

A long "mmm" with the mouth closed vibrates in the sinuses and lengthens the exhalation, which calms the breath and pulse. Ordinary humming does the same. Stories that "Om" is the "sound of the universe" in the physical sense are religious poetry, not physics.

Hypogeum of Ħal Saflieni, Malta

There is research, but results are uncertain

An underground temple carved in rock. In the "Oracle Room" a low male voice echoes throughout the interior, and measurements show a strong resonance of about 110–114 Hz. Did the builders want this effect? We do not know.

The chirping pyramid, Chichén Itzá

Measured and confirmed

Clap in front of the steps of the Pyramid of Kukulkan, and the echo comes back as a chirp similar to the voice of the sacred bird, the quetzal. The physics of this echo is explained: the steps act like a diffraction grating. Whether the Maya did it on purpose remains disputed.

Stonehenge as a concert hall

Measured and confirmed

Acousticians from Salford built a 1:12 scale model of the stone circle. In the complete circle the voice and a drum sounded louder, with a reverberation of about 0.6 s, but only for people inside. Those outside heard little.

Tombs that hum

Measured and confirmed

In 1996 the resonances of six ancient chambers in the British Isles were measured, mainly Neolithic tombs, including Newgrange. Each had a strong resonance at about 95–120 Hz, in the range of a low male voice.

Paintings where the echo is

There is research, but results are uncertain

Iégor Reznikoff sang in caves in France and noticed that many paintings decorate the places with the strongest echo. Perhaps our ancestors chose them for ceremonies with song. It is an interesting observation, not proof.

The power of sound

Nature makes sounds and acts with forces that sound like a fairy tale yet have been measured. Alongside them circulate theories that no one has measured.

Singing dunes

Measured and confirmed

When an avalanche of sand slides down the crest of a dry dune, the desert can boom like an organ, at about 70–110 Hz, audible from a kilometre away. Marco Polo described this in the Gobi Desert. The grains rub against each other in unison.

The Earth hums

Measured and confirmed

The whole planet vibrates constantly, even without earthquakes. These very slow oscillations, one every few minutes, set off ocean waves that beat against the seabed. The ear cannot hear them; only seismometers sense them.

Schumann resonance

Measured and confirmed

Between the ground and the ionosphere, lightning excites radio waves with a frequency of about 7.8 Hz. Winfried Schumann predicted them in 1952, and they were measured in 1960. It is a real electromagnetic phenomenon.

The “Earth's pulse” is rising

Legend, theory or pseudoscience

The internet claims that the Schumann resonance is “rising”, “retunes human consciousness”, or that the brain has to “vibrate” with it. The charts that supposedly show this are interference in data from measuring stations. People do not pick up radio waves of such low power.

Ball lightning

Measured and confirmed

A glowing ball the size of a ball that floats after a storm and disappears. It was long considered a fairy tale. In 2012, Chinese scientists accidentally recorded one with a camera and a spectrometer: it glowed with silicon, iron and calcium from the soil. The cause is still disputed.

Birds see the magnetic field

Measured and confirmed

The robin flies at night with a compass in its eye. The protein cryptochrome in the retina reacts to the Earth's magnetic field, and the mechanism is based on quantum physics. A 2021 study of this protein provided important evidence, although it is still not known for certain whether it is the compass.

The aurora you can hear

There is research, but results are uncertain

For centuries, people of the North have said that the aurora crackles and claps. The Finnish researcher Unto Laine recorded such crackling and believes it arises in a temperature inversion layer about 70 m above the ground. Other scientists are waiting for confirmation.

Song of the cosmos: whistlers and the dawn chorus

Measured and confirmed

A very-low-frequency radio receiver turns waves from the magnetosphere into sound. Lightning produces a falling “whistle”, and at dawn electrons in the radiation belts “chirp” like birds. You can literally hear it through a speaker.

Infrasound and “ghosts”

There is research, but results are uncertain

The engineer Vic Tandy sensed someone's presence in his laboratory until he found a fan vibrating at a frequency of 19 Hz. When it was switched off, the “ghost” disappeared. In 2003, at a concert with hidden infrasound, listeners more often described strange sensations. The evidence is interesting, but modest.

“Pyramid energy”

Legend, theory or pseudoscience

In the 1950s, the Czech Karel Drbal patented a cardboard pyramid under which razor blades were supposed to sharpen themselves. Later, pyramids were supposed to mummify fruit and heal. Controlled trials showed no difference between a pyramid and a box.

Ley lines

Legend, theory or pseudoscience

In 1921, Alfred Watkins noticed that old churches, mounds and stones line up in straight lines, and took them to be ancient trackways. Later “energy lines” were added to them. With so many historic sites on a map, straight lines appear by chance, which has been checked statistically.

The “brown note”

Legend, theory or pseudoscience

The legend tells of an infrasound that makes you lose control of your bowels. Tests, including on the show MythBusters, did not produce such an effect. A very loud low-frequency sound does, however, cause chest tremors and nausea.

Sources

Check for yourself

  1. The table carries sound. Press your ear to the tabletop while someone gently scratches the other end with a fingernail. Then listen to the same thing with your head raised above the table: wood carries sound better than air.
  2. Dancing salt. Stretch cling film over a bowl like a drum and sprinkle a pinch of salt on it. Play a low tone of 100 to 200 Hz from a phone next to it: the salt will arrange itself into lines and patches, and at a different tone into a different pattern. Moderate volume, protect your hearing.
  3. 432 or 440, blind test. Have someone play you the same piece once tuned to 440 Hz and once retuned to 432 Hz, in random order. Guess 10 times which one is 432 and which sounds more soothing.
  4. Pythagoras’ string. Measure a guitar string with a ruler and press it exactly at the halfway point, at the 12th fret. You will hear an octave higher; at 2/3 of the length (7th fret) a fifth sounds.

Did you know…