Magic is not the spells of fairy tales. It is one of the oldest ways in which people have tried to gain control over the weather, illness, love and fate. Anthropologists, historians and psychologists have been studying it for 150 years. Here is what they have learned.
The green face, pointed hat, cat and bubbling cauldron are an image from fairy tales, illustrations and films. The witch's green skin was cemented by the film “The Wizard of Oz” (1939).
Real magic was the everyday practice of ordinary people and priests: charming away an illness with a whisper, an amulet above the threshold, divination from wax, a curse scratched into lead. People believed that with word, gesture and object they could influence the world.
What magic is
Magic is the belief that a word, a gesture or an object can influence the world, people and spirits. In 1890 the anthropologist James Frazer described two of its principles in “The Golden Bough”. The first is similarity: like produces like, so a little doll can “stand in” for a person. The second is contact: a thing that once touched someone remains forever bound to them, for example hair, nails or clothing. For thousands of years the boundary between magic, religion and early science was fluid.
The principle of similarity: like produces like. During droughts in the Balkans (Serbia, Bulgaria, Romania) a girl dressed in greenery was doused with water to “bring” rain. The dodola rite was still performed in the 20th century.
The principle of contact: what was once in contact stays connected. That is why in many cultures people guarded cut hair and nails, so that no one could use them to cast a spell on their owner.
Frazer believed that humanity moves in succession from magic through religion to science. Today anthropologists reject this scheme: these three ways of thinking live side by side in every society, ours included.
Magic commands: if I do this and that, such and such will happen. It works like a recipe, without asking anyone for permission.
Religion asks: through prayer and sacrifice it turns to gods or to God, who may refuse.
Science tests: it runs experiments, counts the results and rejects what does not work.
When people turn to magic
The Polish anthropologist Bronisław Malinowski lived among the inhabitants of the Trobriand Islands. In his essay “Magic, Science and Religion” (1925) he noticed a simple rule: people turn to magic where knowledge and skill do not give certainty.
In the calm lagoon the catch is certain and safe. The fishermen of the Trobriand Islands fished here without any magic.
On the open sea storms lurk and the catch is uncertain. Many rituals were performed before such a trip out to sea.
In 1971 the anthropologist and former baseball player George Gmelch tested this on the field. Players had the most rituals when batting, where even the best hit about 3 times in 10. When fielding, which succeeds about 97–98% of the time, there were almost no rituals.
Mages
The Magi of Persia · Persia and Media, from the 6th century BC
The word “magic” comes from the Greek magos, which comes from Old Persian maguš. This was the name for the priests who guarded the sacred fire. Herodotus wrote of the Magi as one of the tribes of the Medes.
The āšipu of Mesopotamia · Babylonia and Assyria
The āšipu was an exorcist and healer. In the Maqlû (“Burning”) rite he burned figurines of the sorcerer to destroy the spell cast on a sick person. The incantations were written in cuneiform on clay tablets.
Heka in Egypt · Egypt of the pharaohs
The Egyptians called magic heka and worshipped it as the god Heka. It was not forbidden; it was part of religion and medicine. The spells were read from papyrus scrolls by lector priests.
The druids · Gaul and Britain
Priests, judges and scholars of the Celts. They did not write their knowledge down, so we know them from the accounts of the Romans. Pliny described how a druid in white cut mistletoe from an oak with a golden sickle.
The žerci of Svantevit · Arkona on Rügen, until 1168
Priests of the Polabian Slavs. According to Saxo Grammaticus, once a year they checked the horn of drink in the hand of the statue of Svantevit and from how much it had gone down they divined the harvest.
The szeptuchy of Podlasie · Podlasie, to this day
Healers connected with the Orthodox tradition. They “charm away” illness with whispered prayers and use herbs and wax. They are a living trace of old folk magic, although they themselves regard what they do as prayer.
Words of power
ABRAKADABRA · Rome, 3rd century
An inscription in a triangle, each line one letter shorter, worn around the neck. The fever was supposed to weaken just as the word did.
The SATOR square · Pompeii, before AD 79
SATOR AREPO TENET OPERA ROTAS is a Latin palindrome that reads the same in every direction. It was found in the ruins of Pompeii, and in the Middle Ages it was written on amulets and doors.
Bone to bone · Merseburg charm
“Ben zi bena, bluot zi bluoda, lid zi geliden”, that is “bone to bone, blood to blood, joint to joint, as if they were glued”. Similar formulas were known from India to Scandinavia.
I bind your tongue · Greek curse tablet
A typical curse “bound” the tongue, hands and feet of an opponent so that he would lose in court or at the chariot races. The victim's name was inscribed on lead.
Hocus pocus · XVII w.
Where does this formula come from? According to a popular theory from 1694, it is a distortion of the Latin words from the Mass, “hoc est corpus”. Others see in it mere word play. There is no certainty.
Why magic sometimes “works”
Placebo
An empty pill can ease pain if we believe in it. In 1978 it was shown that a drug that blocks endorphins (naloxone) weakens this effect. So belief sets off real substances in the brain.
Nocebo
It works the other way, too. The physiologist Walter Cannon described in 1942 cases of people who became seriously ill after coming to believe that a curse had been cast on them. Fear can truly harm.
A ritual calms
A short ritual before a stressful task lowered anxiety and heart rate, and the results were better. Even a ritual invented for the purposes of the study worked. Under the influence of anxiety, people make their own movements more repetitive, that is, ritualised.
The illusion of control
People who had picked their own lottery ticket wanted, on average, more than 4 times as much to sell it back as those who were assigned a ticket. Choosing gives the illusion that we have influence over chance.
Superstitious pigeons
In 1948 B.F. Skinner fed pigeons about every 15 seconds, regardless of what they were doing. The birds repeated the movement they happened to be making when food came: turning in circles or bobbing their heads. This is how superstition is born.
A lucky charm?
In 2010 a study suggested that a talisman improves performance, e.g. in golf. When other scientists repeated the experiment in 2014, there was no effect. That is how science works: it checks again.
Magic on stage
Stage magic does not pretend to cast spells. It is the art of deceiving attention. The trick with cups and balls was already mentioned by Seneca in the 1st century AD.
You look but you do not see
In 2005 researchers tracked the gaze of people watching a trick with a vanishing cigarette. Many looked straight at the magician's hand and still did not notice the cigarette fall. The eyes see, but attention is somewhere else.
The illusionist versus the mediums
Harry Houdini knew all the tricks, so he exposed the spiritualists who pretended to contact spirits. He described this in his book “A Magician Among the Spirits” (1924).
Seneca's cups
In a letter to Lucilius, Seneca compared clever sophisms to the jugglers' “cups and pebbles”. The same trick has been entertaining people for 2000 years.
The history of magic
c. 15,000 years ago · The Sorcerer of the cave
In the Trois-Frères cave in France a figure half man, half stag was painted, called “the Sorcerer”. Some researchers see in it a shaman, others a deity. There is no certainty.
2nd–1st millennium BC · Spells of Mesopotamia
The Babylonians recorded on clay tablets spells against demons and sorcerers. The Maqlû ritual, meaning “burning”, consisted of burning figurines of hostile sorcerers.
ancient Egypt · Heka and the Eye of Horus
The Egyptians believed in heka, the magical force by which the world was created. Amulets with the Eye of Horus protected the living and the dead.
Greece and Rome · Curse tablets
Curses against rivals in sport, in court and in love were written on lead sheets, pierced with a nail and thrown into wells or graves. Archaeologists have found over a thousand of them.
III w. n.e. · Abracadabra
The physician Serenus Sammonicus recommended an amulet against fever: the word ABRACADABRA written in a triangle, each line shorter by one letter. The illness was supposed to disappear along with the letters.
X w. · The Merseburg Charms
Two pagan spells added in the 10th century to an older manuscript. They were found in 1841 by Georg Waitz in the library of Merseburg Cathedral. The second one heals the sprained leg of the foal of a god, who is usually identified with Baldr.
1486 · The Hammer of Witches
The Dominican Heinrich Kramer published the “Malleus Maleficarum”, a manual for the prosecution of witches. A Polish translation of it appeared in 1614.
1584 · John Dee in Kraków
The English scholar and magus John Dee came to Poland with Edward Kelley, together with the magnate Albert Łaski. In Kraków and Prague they held séances with “angels” through a crystal.
1604 · Sędziwój (Sendivogius), a Polish alchemist
Michał Sędziwój published the “Novum Lumen Chymicum”, read by alchemists throughout Europe. He wrote of a “food of life” in the air, which some regard as a premonition of oxygen.
1776 · The end of the pyres in Poland
The Sejm banned torture and the death penalty in witchcraft trials. Earlier, in 1762, women accused of witchcraft were burned in Doruchów. It was one of the last such executions in Poland.
1888 · Golden Dawn
In London the secret society Hermetic Order of the Golden Dawn was founded, combining Kabbalah, tarot and astrology. It shaped modern occultism.
XX w. · Houdini versus the mediums
The master of illusion Harry Houdini exposed spiritualists who supposedly spoke with the dead. He showed that these were the same tricks he performed himself on stage.
Pyres and witch hunts
The darkest chapter in the history of magic concerns not sorcerers but their victims. Between the 15th and 18th centuries, according to historians, about 40–60 thousand people were executed for witchcraft in Europe, mostly women. Accusations were stirred up by famine, plague, neighbourly quarrels and fear. Confessions were extracted by torture. In Salem in America in 1692, 20 people were executed. In Poland the trials took place mainly before town courts, until in 1776 the Sejm banned torture and the death penalty for witchcraft.
40–60 thousand people executed for witchcraft in Europe, 15th–18th century
1776 The Sejm abolishes torture and the death penalty for witchcraft
1811 Reszel: Barbara Zdunk burned, formally for arson
Magical Poland
Poland has its own rich history of magic. According to legend, witches flew in to Łysa Góra in the Holy Cross Mountains. Pan Twardowski was said to have sold his soul to the devil and ended up on the Moon. In Podlasie the szeptuchy are still active, and on Kupała night people look for the fern flower.
Łysa Góra
According to legend, witches flew in to sabbaths above Łysa Góra in the Holy Cross Mountains. Before Christianity there was a pagan place of worship on the summit.
Kraków
The city of Pan Twardowski, who according to legend signed a pact with the devil and then escaped him to the Moon. In 1584 the English magus John Dee was a guest here.
Węgrów
In the church in Węgrów hangs “Twardowski's mirror”. According to legend the sorcerer used it for his spells.
Podlasie
The szeptuchy from the area around Bielsk Podlaski whisper prayers and formulas over the sick. This is a living tradition of folk medicine.
Doruchów
According to tradition, in 1775 several women accused of witchcraft were burned here. The sources rather confirm the burning of women in Doruchów in 1762, and in 1776 the Sejm banned such trials.
Łukowica
Michał Sędziwój, the most famous Polish alchemist, was born in Łukowica, studied in Kraków and worked for King Sigismund III and Emperor Rudolf II. His work was read by alchemists throughout Europe.
Legends
Baba Yaga
A Slavic witch from a hut on chicken legs, who flies in a mortar and sweeps away her tracks with a broom. Sometimes she helps heroes, sometimes she wants to eat them.
Pan Twardowski
The Polish Faust. He sold his soul to the devil, but stipulated that the devil could take him only in Rome. The devil caught him in an inn called “Rome”, and Twardowski, escaping, got stuck on the Moon.
Fern flower
On Kupała night it was supposed to bloom for a single moment and bring luck to the finder. Ferns do not flower at all, because they reproduce by spores.
Merlin
A wizard of the Arthurian legends, adviser to King Arthur. In the stories he raised the stone circles of Stonehenge and foresaw the future.
The Golem
According to the Prague legend, Rabbi Löw fashioned a giant from clay and brought it to life with a secret word so that it would defend the ghetto. When the golem got out of control, the rabbi stopped it by removing the word.
Faust
A scholar who signed a pact with the devil for knowledge and pleasure. The story of the real 16th-century Johann Faust inspired Marlowe and Goethe.
Curiosities
The last of the magicians
The economist John Maynard Keynes bought Newton's manuscripts and was surprised by their content. He called him “not the first of the age of reason, but the last of the magicians”.
The fern does not flower
The fern flower is pure legend. Ferns reproduce by spores and never produce flowers.
A cat to the stake
In the Middle Ages black cats were sometimes killed as allies of witches. In Japan a black cat is regarded as a lucky talisman.
The lucky horseshoe
The horseshoe was made of iron, and iron was supposed to scare off evil spirits and fairies. It was hung over the door.
Łysa Góra, full of spirits
The monastery on Łysiec in the Holy Cross Mountains was built on the site of a pagan cult. The legends about witches have survived to this day.
The mirror in the church
Twardowski's mirror in Węgrów bears an inscription in Latin: “Luserat hoc speculo magicas Twardovius artes”, that is “Twardowski played at magic arts with this mirror”.
The Pompeii puzzle
The SATOR square was found in Pompeii, which was buried by the volcano in AD 79. It is one of the oldest known “magical” inscriptions.
Houdini and the promise
Houdini agreed a secret code word with his wife. If after death he managed to speak through a medium, he would say it. For years séances were held on the anniversary of his death. The code word was never spoken.
Talisman blind test. Someone else puts a talisman in one of two envelopes and an ordinary pebble in the other, and shuffles them. Throw a paper ball into a basket 10 times from 2 m with each envelope in your pocket; only then check which was which.
Lucky gesture. Toss a coin 20 times, guessing heads or tails, and write down your hits. Then do 20 tosses with a “lucky” gesture before each one. Chance gives about 10 hits in both series.
St Andrew’s Eve wax. Pour a little melted candle wax through a keyhole into cold water. Show the shape to three people separately and write down what each one sees. Candle and hot wax only under adult supervision. Keep the water away from the flame.
The SATOR square. Write SATOR, AREPO, TENET, OPERA, ROTAS into a 5 by 5 grid and read the square in four directions. Check whether it really comes out the same.
Did you know…
A horoscope for everyone. In 1948 the psychologist Bertram Forer gave students a “personal” personality description. They rated its accuracy at 4.3 on average on a scale of 0 to 5, although everyone had received an identical text. Wikipedia: Barnum effect
Faraday and the turning tables. Michael Faraday built a device that showed that the tables at séances are moved by the unconscious hand movements of the participants, not by spirits. Wikipedia: Table-turning
Clever Hans. The horse Hans “counted” by tapping his hoof. In 1907 the psychologist Oskar Pfungst showed that the horse was not counting but reading the involuntary reactions of his trainer. Wikipedia: Clever Hans