
The Pollock twins
The sisters who came back to Hexham · ur. 1958
Two sisters were killed by a car. A year later their father had twin girls, and one had birthmarks in the same places as the dead daughter.
Investigated case: researchers checked the facts and witnesses; some of it fits, but the explanation remains disputed.
The tale
In May 1957, in the town of Hexham in northern England, a car drove onto the pavement and killed two sisters, eleven-year-old Joanna and six-year-old Jacqueline Pollock. Their father John had long believed in reincarnation and kept saying that his daughters would come back to him.
In October 1958 his wife gave birth to twin girls, Gillian and Jennifer. Jennifer had a birthmark on her forehead in the place where Jacqueline had a scar from a fall, and another on her hip, just like her sister. When the family briefly returned to Hexham, the girls were said to recognise a school and a playground they did not know.
The parents said the twins were afraid of cars and played a game in which one held the other's head, saying that "blood is coming from the eyes". Around the age of five they stopped talking about it.
What was checked
Ian Stevenson talked with the family and described the case in his books. The deaths of the sisters and the twins' birth dates are well documented, and the birthmarks were visible in photographs.
What the critics say
The main objection: the father was a zealous believer in reincarnation and was waiting for signs from the start. Children raised in such a belief may unconsciously take over the adults' stories, and parents may remember only what fits.
Other stories
Shanti DeviThe girl who returned to Mathura
James LeiningerThe little pilot from Louisiana
Ryan HammonsThe boy who remembered Hollywood
Omm SetyThe Englishwoman who returned to Abydos
Imad ElawarThe boy from a Druze village
Swarnlata MishraThe girl who sang a foreign song
Cameron MacaulayThe boy from Glasgow and the island of Barra
Finding the Dalai LamaHow the 14th Dalai Lama was sought
Bridey MurphyThe Irishwoman who never existed
General George PattonA soldier of many wars
Henry FordThe carmaker who believed in many lives
Juliusz SłowackiThe Polish bard and the wandering of the spirit
Pythagoras and the puppyThe philosopher who recognised a friend's voice
Edgar CayceThe sleeping prophet from KentuckySources
- I. Stevenson, Children Who Remember Previous Lives, 1987
- I. Stevenson, Reincarnation and Biology, 1997