
Shanti Devi
The girl who returned to Mathura · 1926–1987
A four-year-old girl from Delhi claimed to have a husband and a son in a city a hundred and forty kilometres away. Mahatma Gandhi took an interest in the matter.
Investigated case: researchers checked the facts and witnesses; some of it fits, but the explanation remains disputed.
The tale
Shanti Devi was born in Delhi in 1926. When she was about four, she began to say that her real home was in Mathura, that her name had been Lugdi, that she had a husband who ran a shop, and that she had died shortly after giving birth to a son. For a long time she would not say her husband's name, because in her region a wife did not pronounce her husband's name.
The family wrote to Mathura. It turned out that a merchant, Kedarnath Chaubey, had lived there, whose wife Lugdi Devi had died in 1925, ten days after childbirth. Kedarnath came to Delhi, passing himself off as his own brother. According to accounts, the girl recognised him at once and talked with him about matters that only spouses knew.
The story reached the newspapers, and Gandhi appointed a commission. In November 1935 its members travelled with nine-year-old Shanti to Mathura. According to the report she led the horse-drawn carriage to her former home, recognised relatives and spoke the local dialect. She also pointed out the place where she was supposed to have hidden money. The hiding place was empty, and Kedarnath admitted that he had taken it after his wife's death.
What was checked
In its 1936 report the commission concluded that Shanti Devi had been Lugdi Devi. Later the researchers Ian Stevenson and K. S. Rawat talked with her. Shanti Devi never married and said until the end of her life that she remembered that life.
What the critics say
Another researcher, Bal Chand Nahata, wrote as early as 1936 that the material gathered does not allow one to regard it as proof of reincarnation. It was pointed out that the case was widely publicised in the press, and that witnesses and commission members believed in rebirth, so they may have unconsciously prompted the child.
Other stories
James LeiningerThe little pilot from Louisiana
Ryan HammonsThe boy who remembered Hollywood
The Pollock twinsThe sisters who came back to Hexham
Omm SetyThe Englishwoman who returned to Abydos
Imad ElawarThe boy from a Druze village
Swarnlata MishraThe girl who sang a foreign song
Cameron MacaulayThe boy from Glasgow and the island of Barra
Finding the Dalai LamaHow the 14th Dalai Lama was sought
Bridey MurphyThe Irishwoman who never existed
General George PattonA soldier of many wars
Henry FordThe carmaker who believed in many lives
Juliusz SłowackiThe Polish bard and the wandering of the spirit
Pythagoras and the puppyThe philosopher who recognised a friend's voice
Edgar CayceThe sleeping prophet from KentuckySources
- Psi Encyclopedia: Shanti Devi
- L. D. Gupta i in., An Inquiry into the Case of Shanti Devi, Delhi 1936
- I. Stevenson, K. S. Rawat, relacje z rozmów (lata 70. i 80.)