
Pythagoras and the puppy
The philosopher who recognised a friend's voice · VI w. p.n.e.
Pythagoras saw someone beating a dog and cried out: “Stop! That is the soul of my friend, I recognised him by his voice.”
Legend: a story passed down over centuries that cannot be verified.
The tale
The oldest anecdote about reincarnation was written down by the poet Xenophanes, who lived in the time of Pythagoras. When Pythagoras was walking down the street and saw someone beating a puppy, he is said to have shouted for him to stop, because in the whimpering he had recognised the voice of a dead friend.
Later stories say that Pythagoras remembered his earlier lives. He was supposedly Euphorbus, a Trojan warrior, and recognised his old shield in a temple. Pythagoras' students did not eat meat, because a human soul might dwell in an animal.
What was checked
The fragment by Xenophanes is one of the oldest surviving testimonies about Pythagoras. However, Xenophanes was probably writing it mockingly.
What the critics say
We know very little for certain about Pythagoras, and most of the stories were written down several hundred years after his death. It is a legend that shows how long ago people thought about the wandering of souls.
Other stories
Shanti DeviThe girl who returned to Mathura
James LeiningerThe little pilot from Louisiana
Ryan HammonsThe boy who remembered Hollywood
The Pollock twinsThe sisters who came back to Hexham
Omm SetyThe Englishwoman who returned to Abydos
Imad ElawarThe boy from a Druze village
Swarnlata MishraThe girl who sang a foreign song
Cameron MacaulayThe boy from Glasgow and the island of Barra
Finding the Dalai LamaHow the 14th Dalai Lama was sought
Bridey MurphyThe Irishwoman who never existed
General George PattonA soldier of many wars
Henry FordThe carmaker who believed in many lives
Juliusz SłowackiThe Polish bard and the wandering of the spirit
Edgar CayceThe sleeping prophet from KentuckySources
- Ksenofanes, fragment B7 (Diels-Kranz)
- Diogenes Laertios, Żywoty i poglądy słynnych filozofów VIII