
The Mirrors of Archimedes
Could the sun have burned the Roman fleet?
◐ Under study
Roman ships besieged Syracuse. The legend says Archimedes focused the sun's rays with mirrors and set them on fire from afar. It has been tested many times.
Who: Archimedes of Syracuse (according to legend) · When: ok. 213–212 p.n.e. · Where: Syracuse, Sicily
The tale
Archimedes defended his native Syracuse against the Romans. His cranes and catapults truly spread terror. But no author from his own time writes about mirrors. The first mention of fire appears in Lucian almost 400 years later.
In 1973 the Greek engineer Ioannis Sakkas lined up 70 sailors with copper mirrors. They focused light on a plywood model of a ship coated in tar, about 50 meters away. The model caught fire within seconds.
In 2005 MIT students used 127 mirrors, each 30 centimeters on a side, and a wooden ship about 30 meters away. Fire did appear, but only after about 10 minutes, under a cloudless sky and with a motionless target.
The MythBusters program tested it several times, including with 500 schoolchildren holding little mirrors. The sail did not reach the 210 degrees Celsius needed to ignite. Conclusion: mirrors could rather have dazzled the crews than burned the ships.
How it works
- Focusing: Each mirror reflects a patch of sunlight. When many patches land in one spot, the temperature rises.
- Moving target: A ship rocks and sails along. The spot of light has to stay in one place for minutes for the wood to catch fire.
- Sun and time of day: Syracuse faces east, so an attack would have had to come in the morning, under a clear sky. That is a lot of conditions at once.
Investigation: facts and theories
Documented
- Archimedes defended Syracuse in 214–212 BC with war machines.
- The earliest mention of ships being set on fire dates from the 2nd century AD, and of mirrors from around AD 500.
- The 1973 and 2005 trials produced fire only with a motionless target and full sun.
Theories
- The mirrors burned the ships. Supporters' arguments: Sakkas's trial: the model caught fire within seconds. What the documents say: The 1973 experiment, a model coated in tar.
- The mirrors only dazzled. Supporters' arguments: The long time needed to ignite, and the movement of the ships. What the documents say: The MIT and MythBusters tests from 2005–2010.
- A legend added later. Supporters' arguments: No mentions by authors from the time of the siege. What the documents say: Polybius and Livy describe the machines, but not mirrors.
What we don't know: Whether Archimedes experimented with mirrors at all. What metal mirrors the defenders might have had and how well they reflected light.
Check for yourself
- Light spots on the wall: On a sunny day, with friends, point three little mirrors at one spot on a light-colored wall. Never aim at eyes or at people. You will see the spot get brighter and brighter.
- A thermometer in the spot: Put a kitchen thermometer on a dark sheet of paper and aim the spot from one mirror, then from three, at it. Write down the temperature every minute.
- Moving target: Have someone slowly move the sheet. It is hard to keep the spot of light on it. Think of a rocking ship.
What is known for certain
Light focused by mirrors can ignite wood in ideal conditions, as the 1973 and 2005 trials showed. But there is no testimony from Archimedes' time that mirrors were used in battle.