
The big question
Sphere or flat?
Investigation into the shape of the Earth
✦ Confirmed
The Earth is a sphere, or more precisely a sphere slightly flattened at the poles (radius 6378 km at the equator, 6357 km at the poles). This is one of the best-tested things in science.
Claims and evidence
- Flat-Earthers: The horizon always looks flat. Evidence: The Earth is enormous. From eye level the horizon is only 5 km away from you, so the curvature can't be seen. From a plane barely, from a balloon at 35 km clearly.
- Flat-Earthers: Water always finds its level, so the ocean must be flat. Evidence: Level is the direction perpendicular to gravity. Gravity pulls toward the centre of the Earth, so the ocean surface takes the shape of a sphere.
- Flat-Earthers: If the Earth were spinning, we would feel it. Evidence: You don't feel uniform motion, like on a plane. The Earth turns once a day, very gently. The rotation shows up instead in Foucault's pendulum and in the vortices of hurricanes, which spin counterclockwise in the north and clockwise in the south.
- Flat-Earthers: Photos from space are fakes. Evidence: They are taken by the agencies of many competing countries, by private companies and by amateurs with balloons. The space station is visible to the naked eye when it passes over Poland.
- Flat-Earthers: Antarctica is an ice wall around a flat Earth. Evidence: People cross Antarctica overland, e.g. Børge Ousland alone in 1997. Several dozen research stations operate there. A flight from Santiago to Sydney takes about 14 hours, and on a flat map it would be several times longer.
- Flat-Earthers: The Sun is a small lamp circling low above the disc. Evidence: A lamp moving away would get smaller. The Sun at sunset is the same size and hides behind the horizon from below. On a flat Earth its light would always be visible somewhere.
- Flat-Earthers: The ship disappears because of perspective, and binoculars bring it back. Evidence: Perspective shrinks everything evenly. A ship disappears from the bottom up: first the hull, then the masts. Binoculars magnify, but they can't bring back a hull hidden behind the curvature.
- Flat-Earthers: No curvature is visible on the Bedford canal. Evidence: Over water, light bends (refraction). In 1870 Wallace set up poles at equal height and the middle one stuck up above the line. The curvature was there.
Check for yourself
Flat-Earthers are right about one thing: it's worth checking for yourself instead of taking someone's word. That's why below are experiments you can do without any space agency.
- A ship beyond the horizon: Take binoculars to the Baltic and watch a large ship sailing away. First the hull will vanish, then the superstructure, and the masts last.
- Shadow on the Moon: During a lunar eclipse the Earth's shadow is always round, whether the Moon is high or low. Only a sphere casts a round shadow from every side.
- Two sticks like Eratosthenes: Arrange with someone from the other end of Poland. On the same sunny noon, measure the shadow of a vertical stick. The angles will differ, and from the difference you can calculate the circumference of the Earth. Try it in the calculator.
- The Pole Star: The height of the Pole Star above the horizon equals your latitude: in Gdańsk about 54°, in Zakopane about 49°. You won't see the Southern Cross from Poland at all.
- Call Japan: When it's noon here, it's 7 or 8 pm in Tokyo and 6 am in New York. The Sun always lights half of the globe.
- Two sunsets: Lie down on the beach and watch until the sun disappears. Then stand up quickly. You'll see it once more, because from a higher point you can see farther beyond the curvature.
How people discovered the shape of the Earth
- ok. 500 p.n.e. · The Pythagoreans: The first Greeks to speak of a spherical Earth.
- ok. 350 p.n.e. · Aristotle: He proves the sphericity: the Earth's shadow on the Moon is always round, and the stars change as you travel south.
- ok. 240 p.n.e. · Eratosthenes: He measures shadows in Alexandria and Syene and calculates the circumference of the Earth with an error of a few to a dozen or so percent.
- 1230 · The Middle Ages: Sacrobosco's textbook On the Sphere teaches students across Europe that the Earth is a sphere. The myth of the flat Earth in the Middle Ages only arose in the 19th century.
- 1519–1522 · Magellan and Elcano: The first circumnavigation of the globe. They sail west and return from the east.
- 1838 · Bedford Level: Samuel Rowbotham looks along 10 km of canal and claims the curvature can't be seen. The modern flat-Earth movement is born.
- 1870 · Alfred Wallace: He repeats the experiment with poles of equal height and shows the curvature. He wins the bet.
- 1961 · Gagarin: The first person to orbit the Earth in space.
- 1972 · The Blue Marble: The crew of Apollo 17 photographs the whole, round Earth.
- od 2014 · The return of the flat-Earthers: Videos on the internet revive the movement. Today any amateur can release a balloon with a camera up to 30 km and check it themselves.