
The femur and the Eiffel Tower
A beautiful story with a real beginning and an added ending
◐ Under study
An anatomist showed an engineer a sectioned femur. The engineer exclaimed: “That is my crane!” Did the Eiffel Tower grow out of that bone twenty years later?
Who: Hermann von Meyer, Karl Culmann, Maurice Koechlin · When: 1866–1889 · Where: Zurich, Switzerland and Paris, France
Nature and invention
The inside of the head of the femur is a spongy network of small beams. They line up along the lines the pressure from body weight follows.
Graphic statics, that is, drawing lines of force in structures, and trusses, which give great strength with little material.
The tale
In the 1860s in Zurich, the anatomist Hermann von Meyer studied cross-sections of bone. He noticed that the small beams in the head of the femur do not lie at random but form arches, as if someone had designed them.
He showed the drawings to Karl Culmann, a professor of engineering who was just then developing graphic statics. Culmann recognised in them the stress lines he was calculating for a curved crane. The meeting inspired the surgeon Julius Wolff, who declared that bone remodels itself according to load. That is Wolff's law today.
Now the added ending. We often hear that the Eiffel Tower was designed on the model of the femur. The design was indeed drawn by Maurice Koechlin, who in 1873–1877 studied in Zurich precisely under Culmann. He may have known the story of the bone.
There is, however, no record that Koechlin or Eiffel thought about bone. The biomimetics researcher Julian Vincent calls this version a fairy tale. The tower was calculated for wind pressure, and its shape results from calculations. The common ancestor of bone and tower is rather the same way of thinking about forces.
How it works
- Lines of pressure: Body weight presses on the head of the bone from above and from the side. The small beams line up along the directions of compression and tension.
- Little material: Bone is hollow and open-work inside. There is material only where the forces flow.
- The lattice: The Eiffel Tower is open-work too: iron lattices take the forces and the rest is air. That is why it weighs less than its size suggests.
Investigation: facts and theories
Documented
- In the 1860s Meyer and Culmann compared the small beams of the femur with the stress lines in a crane.
- Maurice Koechlin studied in 1873–1877 at the Polytechnic in Zurich under Carl Culmann.
- Koechlin and Émile Nouguier are the authors of the first design of the tower, from 1884.
Theories
- A tower copied from bone. Supporters' arguments: Koechlin knew Culmann's school, and the shape of the tower resembles a bone that widens toward the bottom. What the documents say: There are no notes, letters or statements linking the design to bone.
- A shared school of thought. Supporters' arguments: Culmann taught how to draw the flow of forces. The same method was used by the description of the bone and by the design of trusses. What the documents say: Koechlin's studies under Culmann are confirmed in biographies.
What we don't know: Whether Koechlin ever saw Meyer's drawings of bone. Whether Culmann's crane was drawn as curved from the start, or was fitted to the bone later.
Check for yourself
- A soup bone: Ask at home for a cut soup bone, or get one from the butcher. Look at the spongy centre through a magnifying glass. You will see small beams arranged in arches.
- A pasta tower: Build two towers of the same height from dry spaghetti and plasticine: one solid, the other made of triangles. Test which will carry more coins with fewer sticks.
- A straw and paper: Roll a sheet of paper into a tube and stand a book on it. Then fold an identical sheet flat and try the same. Shape turns paper into a structure.
What is known for certain
The meeting of Meyer and Culmann in the 1860s is well documented and gave rise to Wolff's law. Koechlin was indeed Culmann's student. A direct influence of the femur on the design of the Eiffel Tower has no document behind it, and specialists regard it as an embellishment.