
Humpback fins
Bumps that looked like a sculptor's mistake
✦ Confirmed
A biologist saw a figurine of a humpback whale and thought the artist had made a mistake: the bumps were on the leading edge of the flipper. He checked a real whale. The artist was right.
Who: Frank Fish · When: 1995–2011 · Where: Pennsylvania, USA
Nature and invention
The humpback has pectoral fins as long as a third of its body. On their leading edge sit several to a dozen or so large bumps, which help it turn sharply when hunting.
Fan and wind-turbine blades, rudders and wings with a wavy leading edge, which lose lift later.
The tale
The humpback weighs several dozen tonnes, yet it makes loops and tight turns underwater. It hunts by surrounding shoals of fish with a wall of bubbles, and has to spin like a dancer to do so.
Frank Fish, a biologist from Pennsylvania, studied how animals swim. In a souvenir shop near Boston he saw a figurine of a humpback whale with bumps on the leading edge of the flipper and decided the sculptor had made a mistake. Every engineer knew, after all, that the leading edge of a wing should be smooth.
Fish and engineers built models of flippers and put them in a wind tunnel. The flipper with bumps stopped generating lift later, at a steeper angle, and did not lose force suddenly, but gradually.
This idea gave rise to the company WhalePower and to fan blades with a wavy edge. The idea was also tested on wind turbines, rudders and in aviation. It has not caught on everywhere, because the benefits show mainly at large angles, but the principle works.
How it works
- Channels: The bumps split the flow over the flipper into narrower streams. Small swirls form between the bumps.
- Swirls hold on: The swirls draw fast water inward and keep it from separating from the surface. The flipper holds its lift for longer.
- A gentle stall: An ordinary wing suddenly loses lift at too steep an angle. With bumps the drop is gradual, so it is easier to control.
Check for yourself
- A hand out of the window: At a stop, ask an adult for a fan set to low speed. Hold a flat hand in front of it and slowly raise its front edge. At some point you will feel the upward push weaken. That is a stall.
- Two cardboard wings: Cut two identical wings from cardboard. On one, glue a few plasticine balls to the leading edge. Launch them like gliders from the same height and compare the flight.
- Count the bumps: Look online at close-up photos of a humpback and count the bumps on the flipper. Check whether they get smaller toward the tip of the flipper.
What is known for certain
Wind-tunnel experiments showed that the bumps delay the stall, increase the maximum lift and reduce drag (Fish et al., Integrative and Comparative Biology, 2011). The benefit depends on the size and spacing of the bumps and on the flow conditions.