
Gustave Whitehead
Did he fly before the Wright brothers?
◐ Under study
A newspaper from August 1901 describes a flight of an airplane for half a mile. The Wright brothers flew two years later. Who deserves to be first?
Who: Gustave Whitehead (Gustav Weißkopf) · When: 1901–1902 · Where: Bridgeport and Fairfield, Connecticut, USA
The tale
Gustav Weißkopf was born in Bavaria, in Leutershausen. In America he changed his surname to Whitehead and worked in factories, devoting every free moment to flying machines.
In June 1901 the magazine Scientific American published photographs of his machine number 21: a lightweight construction with bat-like wings that, with the wings folded, could be driven like a car.
On 18 August 1901 the weekly Bridgeport Herald described, as an eyewitness account, that four days earlier Whitehead had flown about half a mile at a height of about 15 meters and landed safely. Reprints appeared in newspapers in New York, Boston and Washington.
In the 1930s statements were collected from people who remembered his flights. No photograph of the flight itself has been found, however. In 2013 the editors of the respected yearbook Jane's All the World's Aircraft recognized him as the first. Most aviation historians still disagree.
How it works
- Machine no. 21: Wings of canvas on bamboo ribs, two propellers and an engine. On the ground a separate engine drove the wheels.
- The flight according to the newspaper: About half a mile of flight, a height of about 15 meters, a calm landing.
- Replicas: Replicas that flew have been built in the USA and Germany. They had modern engines and changes to the design, however.
Investigation: facts and theories
Documented
- Scientific American showed Whitehead's machine in June 1901.
- The Bridgeport Herald of 18 August 1901 described a flight from 14 August.
- In 1968 Connecticut recognized him as the father of the state's aviation.
Theories
- He flew first. Supporters' arguments: A press report, later witness statements, Jane's opinion from 2013. What the documents say: Articles from 1901 and testimony from the 1930s.
- The flight was not proven. Supporters' arguments: No photograph of the flight, Whitehead did not repeat the flights in public, no further development of his design. What the documents say: The position of the Smithsonian Institution and the editors of Scientific American.
- A dispute distorted by a contract. Supporters' arguments: The Smithsonian has an agreement with Orville Wright's heirs to recognize the priority of the Wrights' 1903 airplane. What the documents say: The agreement exists and was criticized in the 1978 book History by Contract.
What we don't know: Whether the flight of 14 August 1901 took place as the newspaper described. Whether a photograph of the machine in flight, which his supporters spoke of, ever existed.
Check for yourself
- A glider from a sheet of paper: Fold a paper airplane and measure how far it flies. Add a paper clip at the front and measure again. The center of gravity decides the flight.
- A bat wing: Cut a bat-shaped wing out of foil and stick it to skewers. Compare how it glides with a simple rectangular wing.
- Be a historian: Write down on a sheet what evidence you have for what you did yesterday: a photo, a witness, a ticket. Then think about what is missing in Whitehead's case.
What is known for certain
Machine no. 21 existed, as photographs from 1901 show. The flight described in the Bridgeport Herald has no photograph or independent documentation from those days. The matter remains disputed.