
Great Tartary
A lost empire that vanished from the textbooks?
☾ Unconfirmed
On old maps a huge area of Asia bears the name Tartary. A theory circulating on the internet says it was an advanced empire that was deliberately erased from history.
Who: An internet theory (since about 2016) · When: maps from the 16th–19th c. · Where: Central Asia and Siberia
The tale
You open an old map from the 18th century. From the Caspian Sea to the Pacific stretches a land labelled "Tartary". The 1771 Encyclopaedia Britannica described it as a vast country in the northern part of Asia.
Supporters of the theory say: it was an empire with knowledge that we do not have. Free energy from the air, magnificent buildings all over the world. A catastrophe followed, and someone rewrote history.
In the Polish and Russian internet Tartary is often linked with the Slavs: it was supposedly the ancient homeland of the Slavs and Aryans. These threads come from Russian "alternative history", among others from Anatoly Fomenko's "New Chronology" of the 1990s.
It is a beautiful tale of a lost world. Let us see what is left of it when we set it against the sources.
Theory versus historians
- Theory: Tartary is on hundreds of old maps, so it must have been a state. Historians: Tartary is the name Europeans gave to the whole of Asia, which they knew poorly, after the Tatars. They wrote "Terra incognita" in the same way. The Russian Geographical Society holds these maps in its collections and confirms: the name existed, the state did not.
- Theory: The 1771 Encyclopaedia Britannica describes Tartary as the largest country in the world. Historians: The same entry divides it into parts ruled by different rulers: Russia, China and nomadic peoples. It is a description of a region, not of a single empire.
- Theory: Tartary was erased from history because it was too powerful. Historians: The history of these lands is well described: the Golden Horde, the khanates, the Mongol empire, the colonisation of Siberia. Only the traces of one lost state are missing: coins, documents, writings, tombs.
- Theory: Tartary was the homeland of the Slavs. Historians: It was inhabited mainly by Turkic, Mongol and Tungusic peoples, and from the 16th century by more and more Russian settlers. The cradle of the Slavs, according to archaeologists and linguists, lay in Central and Eastern Europe, between the Vistula and the Dnieper.
How it was meant to work
- Where the name comes from: The Tatars are a people, but Europeans associated them with the Greek Tartarus, the underground hell. That is how "Tartary" came about.
- Where it is: On the maps: from the Caspian Sea and the Urals to the Pacific, that is today's Kazakhstan, Siberia, Mongolia and Manchuria.
- Why it disappeared: In the 19th century Europeans got to know Asia better and began to call its parts by their proper names. "Tartary" simply fell out of use.
Investigation: facts and theories
Documented
- Hundreds of maps: The name Tartary appears on hundreds of European maps from the 16th to the 19th century, often covering a huge area of Asia.
- Encyklopedia z 1771: The first edition of the Encyclopaedia Britannica (1771) has an entry “Tartary” describing a great country in northern Asia.
- Cities of palaces for a few months: World's fairs put up whole districts of splendid buildings, such as the White City in Chicago in 1893, and tore them down after a few months.
- Raised streets: In the 19th century Chicago, Seattle and other cities raised their street level by a metre or more, so old ground-floor windows ended up underground.
Theories
- Theory: a lost empire. Supporters' arguments: A great state suddenly vanishes from maps and encyclopaedias, while similar magnificent architecture appears all over the world. Buried ground-floor windows look like traces of a catastrophe. What the documents say: To Europeans, Tartary meant the little-known lands of Siberia and Central Asia, inhabited by many peoples. Maps divide it into several parts, e.g. Muscovite Tartary and Chinese Tartary. We know of no coins, laws or chronicles of a single state.
- Theory: the buildings were built by an ancient civilisation. Supporters' arguments: 19th-century buildings are too beautiful and were put up too quickly, and old photos show empty cities. What the documents say: For many of them, plans, invoices, construction photos and the names of architects have survived, e.g. Daniel Burnham for Chicago 1893. Empty streets in old photos are the result of long exposure times: movement didn't register.
What we don't know: The history of the peoples of Siberia and Central Asia is little known in Poland and full of blank spots. It's worth exploring through sources from those lands.
Check for yourself
- Old maps in Polona: Type “Tartaria” into the polona.pl digital library and compare maps from successive centuries. See how its borders changed.
- When your building was built: Pick an old building in your town and find out in an archive or on fotopolska.eu when it was built and by whom.
- Compare photos: Put an old photo of a street next to today's view from the same spot. Write down what has changed.
What is known for certain
Tartary is a real name from old maps, but not a lost empire. Historians and the Russian Geographical Society reject this theory. There are no archaeological traces of a single state, and the history of these lands is well documented.