
The cone that senses rain
Dead scales that move by themselves
✦ Confirmed
Put a cone on a radiator and it opens. Drop it in water and it closes. And yet it is dead. Who moves it?
Who: Colin Dawson, Julian Vincent, Lakshminarayanan Mahadevan and a team from MIT · When: 1997–2017 · Where: Reading, Great Britain and Cambridge, USA
Nature and invention
A cone scale has two layers. One swells with moisture, the other hardly at all. When the humidity changes, the scale bends like a bimetallic thermometer.
Materials and fabrics that open flaps by themselves when humidity rises, for example running wear with flaps that open with sweat.
The tale
A pine cone ripens for a long time, and then it has to release its seeds on the wind. Best on a dry day, so that they fly far. That is why it opens when it is dry and closes in the rain.
In 1997 Colin Dawson, Julian Vincent and Anne-Marie Rocca described in Nature how it works. The cells of a ripe cone are dead, so the movement is entirely passive. It is produced by the structure of the scale and its cell walls alone.
In 2009 Lakshminarayanan Mahadevan of Harvard studied the rate of opening and closing, and then made from paper and plastic an artificial flower that blooms and closes depending on moisture.
In 2017 a team from MIT went further. It applied living bacterial cells, which swell with moisture, to a thin film. From that film it made flaps on the back of a running garment. When the runner sweats, the flaps open slightly and let air in.
How it works
- Two layers: The underside of the scale has fibres that swell strongly with water. The top swells weakly.
- Bending: When one layer grows more than the other, the whole scale bends. A wet scale closes the cone, a dry one opens it.
- No motor: It needs neither electricity nor muscles. A change in humidity is enough, and the movement can be repeated hundreds of times.
Check for yourself
- A cone in a bowl: Drop an open pine cone into a bowl of water. After an hour it will be closed. Take it out and leave it on a windowsill for a day. It will open again.
- A cone in a bottle: Slide a closed, wet cone into a narrow-necked jar. When it dries and opens, it cannot be taken out. Guests will be puzzled.
- A paper scale: Stick together a strip of printer paper and a strip of adhesive tape. Breathe on it or place it on a damp cloth. The strip will bend, because the paper swells and the tape does not.
What is known for certain
The mechanism was described by Dawson, Vincent and Rocca (Nature, 1997), and quantitatively by Reyssat and Mahadevan (Journal of the Royal Society Interface, 2009). A prototype garment with flaps that react to sweat was described in Science Advances in 2017. These are still mainly prototypes, not mass-market clothes.