Enter the forest
Flexible glass
Lost secrets of the masters

Flexible glass

The craftsman who showed the emperor an indestructible bowl

☾ Unconfirmed

The craftsman threw a glass bowl on the ground before the emperor. It did not break, it only dented. He hammered it out with a little hammer. The emperor had him killed.

Who: A nameless craftsman from the story · When: the reign of Tiberius, AD 14–37 · Where: Rome

See the illustrated storyphotos, animations and experiments to do yourself

The tale

The story is told by Petronius in the "Satyricon" and then by Pliny the Elder in the "Natural History". A craftsman brought Emperor Tiberius a bowl of glass that did not shatter.

Before the eyes of the court he threw it on the floor. The bowl only dented. The craftsman took a little hammer from the folds of his toga and calmly hammered it out. He was counting on a great reward.

The emperor asked whether anyone else knew this method. When he heard that no one did, he had the inventor beheaded. He was said to fear that such glass would lower the value of gold and silver. Others added that he wanted to protect the glassworks.

Pliny himself added that this story is "more widespread than certain". We know Roman glass from thousands of finds and none of them is flexible. The historian Robert Forbes supposed that it concerned glass bent while hot, for example in the handles of vessels.

How it was meant to work

  1. Brittle glass: Ordinary glass has no ordered crystals. A small scratch runs on when struck, and the glass breaks instead of bending.
  2. Glass today: Since 2012 Corning has produced Willow Glass, glass so thin that it can be rolled up. Flexible glass exists, but it cannot be hammered out with a hammer.
  3. Tempering: Chemically toughened glass, as in phones, has a compressed surface and withstands much more. But it still breaks rather than bends.

Check for yourself

  1. Glass or plastic: Take an empty jar and a plastic cup. Tap them with your fingernail and listen. Glass rings high and clear, plastic dully. Do not throw anything.
  2. A curved pane: Take a close look at the screen of an old phone with rounded edges. This glass was bent while hot in a factory, not with a hammer.
  3. A story in two versions: Read Pliny's passage on glass (book 36) in translation. Find the sentence in which the author himself admits that he is not sure of this story.

What is known for certain

There is no find or independent source confirming flexible glass in ancient Rome. Pliny himself considered the story uncertain. Modern very thin glass is flexible, but no glass behaves like metal under a hammer.

Why it was lost: According to the story, Emperor Tiberius had the inventor beheaded when he swore that no one but him knew the secret. The recipe was supposed to perish with him.

Sources