Enter the forest
The Stradivarius mystery
Lost secrets of the masters

The Stradivarius mystery

A violin worth millions and a secret that may not exist at all

◐ Under study

A luthier from a small Italian town made more than a thousand instruments. About 650 survived and are worth millions. For three hundred years everyone has been asking: what did he know?

Who: Antonio Stradivari · When: ok. 1666–1737 · Where: Cremona, Italy

See the illustrated storyphotos, animations and experiments to do yourself

The tale

Antonio Stradivari worked in Cremona for more than 60 years. He made violins, violas, cellos, guitars and harps. His best violins date from around 1700–1725, the so-called golden period.

There are plenty of theories about his secret. One speaks of wood from the Little Ice Age: in cold years trees grew slowly and had dense rings. Another of wood soaked in solutions of salts and minerals that protected it from woodworm and fungus. Chemists from Taiwan found traces of aluminium, copper and calcium in Stradivari's wood.

There is also a third possibility, a less romantic one. In 2012 in Indianapolis experienced violinists played old and new violins wearing dark goggles. They could not tell a Stradivarius from a good new instrument, and they rated one Stradivarius the worst.

In 2014 in Paris, ten soloists tested six old Italian and six new violins, also in a concert hall. Most chose a new instrument as their favourite, and guessing which one was old went no better for them than a coin toss.

So perhaps Stradivari's secret is simply brilliant craftsmanship, fame and three hundred years of legend. Or perhaps there is something in the wood that we cannot yet measure. The dispute continues.

How it works

  1. Wood: Spruce for the top plate and maple for the back. Density, stiffness and how fast sound travels in it determine the tone.
  2. Bath: The wood may have been soaked in water with minerals or impregnated with salts protecting against pests. This changes its density and damping.
  3. Shape: The thickness of the plates, the arching and the f-shaped holes tune the body. Stradivari refined them throughout his life.

Investigation: facts and theories

Documented

Theories

What we don't know: Whether the minerals in the wood got there deliberately, or from the water used to float the timber. How these violins sounded 300 years ago, before repairs and replacement of parts. Whether the difference shows up with longer playing in a concert hall.

Check for yourself

  1. A blind test at home: Record the same melody played on two different guitars or violins. Play the recordings to your family in random order and ask them to guess which instrument is more expensive.
  2. Tap the board: Tap with your finger on a dry spruce board and an oak one of the same size. Listen to which rings for longer. Luthiers choose wood in exactly this way.
  3. Jars: Count the rings on a piece of wood from a DIY store and on an old beam from a demolition. Dense rings mean slow growth of the tree.

What is known for certain

Chemical studies confirmed that Stradivari's wood differs from modern wood in its mineral content (PNAS, 2017). Blind tests from 2012 and 2014 (PNAS) showed that violinists and listeners cannot reliably distinguish it from good new instruments. It is not known whether the differences in the wood are audible.

Why it was lost: Stradivari left no recipe for the wood or the varnish. After his death in 1737 the workshop declined, tools and patterns were scattered, and his sons did not keep up their father's standard.

Sources