Enter the forest
The forest internet
Spied from nature

The forest internet

Do trees talk through fungi?

◐ Under study

A forester from Canada showed that carbon travels underground from birch to fir. The world heard: trees have an internet, and old mother trees feed the young. How much of that do we know for sure?

Who: Suzanne Simard · When: 1997–2023 · Where: British Columbia, Canada

See the illustrated storyphotos, animations and experiments to do yourself

Nature and invention

The roots of most trees cooperate with mycorrhizal fungi. The fungus supplies water and mineral salts, and the tree gives it sugars. The hyphae of a single fungus may reach the roots of several trees.

For now not a technology but an idea: designing distributed networks modelled on forest connections, and forest management that protects the fungi in the soil.

The tale

Suzanne Simard grew up in the Canadian forests, in a family that had lived for generations from work in the forest. She became a forest researcher at the University of British Columbia and began to check what happens underground between trees.

In 1997 in Nature she described an experiment with labelled carbon. A birch and a Douglas fir in the forest exchanged carbon, and more in one direction than in the other. The newspapers called it the “wood wide web”, that is, the forest internet.

Then came books and films about mother trees, which recognise their children and send them food and warnings. The story moved millions of people.

In 2023 three researchers, including Melanie Jones, a co-author of the 1997 paper, checked how much of this is confirmed. It turned out that the evidence for the prevalence of such networks and for the transfer of food to seedlings is ambiguous, and there is no published evidence at all for mother trees deliberately feeding their offspring.

Mycorrhizal fungi are nevertheless truly indispensable to the forest. Without them most trees would grow poorly. The question is not whether fungi are important, but whether trees deliberately talk to each other through them.

How it works

  1. The exchange: The fungus wraps around the root and penetrates between its cells. The tree gives sugars, the fungus water, nitrogen and phosphorus.
  2. A shared fungus: One mycelium can touch the roots of several trees. This is how a shared network may form.
  3. Who gives to whom: Labelled carbon from one tree is sometimes found in another. It is not known, however, how much of it passed through the fungus and how much through the soil, or whether it helps the tree.

Investigation: facts and theories

Documented

Theories

What we don't know: How often in a forest mycelial networks really connect many trees at once. Whether transport through the mycelium matters for seedling survival in a natural forest. Whether fungi pass anything on for the trees' benefit, or simply look after themselves.

Check for yourself

  1. Fungi by the trees: In autumn, note under which trees bolete, slippery jack and amanita mushrooms grow. The birch bolete keeps to birch, the slippery jack to pine or larch. These are mycorrhizal pairs.
  2. White threads by the roots: Carefully brush aside the litter near the thin roots of a young pine. White or yellowish sheaths on the root tips are mycorrhiza.
  3. Two seedlings: Plant two oak seedlings: one in soil from the forest, the other in bought bagged soil. After six months compare how they have grown.

What is known for certain

Mycorrhiza and the exchange of substances between tree and fungus are certain. Shared mycelial networks between trees exist, but their extent and significance are disputed. A 2023 review (Karst, Jones, Hoeksema, Nature Ecology and Evolution) found no published evidence that mother trees deliberately feed their offspring.

Sources