
Ochorowicz's telephone and mediums
The inventor of telephones who looked for spirits
◐ Under study
His telephones connected a Paris ministry with the opera. The same man spent years sitting in dark rooms with mediums. Some of his findings were confirmed, some were not.
Who: Julian Ochorowicz · When: 1877–1917 · Where: Paris, Warsaw, Wisła
The tale
Julian Ochorowicz (1850–1917) was a philosopher, psychologist and inventor. He worked in Leipzig with Wilhelm Wundt, the father of experimental psychology. He argued that psychology should be studied like a natural science.
In 1877 he described the idea of television: a screen of light bulbs showing an image broken into dots. He did not know how to build it. In 1885 in Paris he demonstrated his improved telephones, which connected the ministry of posts with the opera house 4 kilometres away, and later Antwerp with Brussels.
He was a friend of Bolesław Prus. Prus portrayed him in “The Doll” as the inventor Julian Ochocki.
Ochorowicz also studied hypnosis and suggestion. He brought the Italian medium Eusapia Palladino to Warsaw, and in his laboratory in Wisła he studied the medium Stanisława Tomczyk. He believed that thought could move objects.
How it works
- The telephone: Ochorowicz improved microphones and receivers so that speech was louder and carried further. He received a French patent for this in 1885.
- Television on paper: An image broken into dots, turned into current and assembled from light bulbs. The principle was right, but the technology of 1877 could not cope.
- Suggestion: He studied how words and expectations change a person's behaviour. He was one of the forerunners of the psychology of the unconscious.
Investigation: facts and theories
Documented
- Ochorowicz's French patent for a telephone system from 1885.
- Demonstrations of telephone connections in Paris over a distance of 4 kilometres.
- Eusapia Palladino was caught cheating in Cambridge in 1895: she freed her hands from the researchers' control.
Theories
- Thought can move objects. Supporters' arguments: Ochorowicz described séances at which objects rose in the presence of a medium. What the documents say: No such phenomenon has been repeated under strict control. The movements were explained by tricks and small movements of the body.
- Suggestion acts on the body. Supporters' arguments: Ochorowicz studied hypnosis and the power of expectations. What the documents say: This has largely been confirmed: the placebo effect and the ideomotor effect are well studied today.
What we don't know: What the details of the experiments in the laboratory in Wisła were like, since mainly the researcher's own accounts have survived.
Check for yourself
- A cup telephone: Connect two yoghurt pots with a taut string 10 metres long. Speak into one while someone listens at the other. The vibrations travel along the string; in Ochorowicz's telephone they travelled along a wire as a current.
- A little pendulum that moves by itself: Hang a ring on a thread and hold it still over a sheet with a small cross. Think hard: go round in a circle. The pendulum will start to circle. These are tiny movements of your hand, the ideomotor effect, not a mysterious force.
- A telepathy test: Take 25 cards with five symbols. Someone draws a card, you guess. Chance gives on average 5 hits out of 25. Write down the results over several days and check whether you get above chance.
What is known for certain
Ochorowicz's telephones worked and were produced for about 20 years. His research on suggestion contributed something to psychology. Mediumistic phenomena were never confirmed under controlled conditions, and Palladino was caught cheating many times.