Enter the forest
Newman's energy machine
Free energy

Newman's energy machine

A motor tested by a state laboratory

☾ Unconfirmed

An American inventor claimed that his motor gave more energy than it received from the batteries. The case went to court, and the court did what is usually missing in such stories: it ordered the motor to be measured.

Who: Joseph Newman · When: 1979–1989 · Where: USA

See the illustrated storyphotos, animations and experiments to do yourself

The tale

Joseph Newman built a direct-current motor with huge coils of copper wire. He claimed the motor converts part of the copper's mass into energy, according to Einstein's formula, and gives more power than it takes in.

In 1979 he filed a patent application. The office refused in 1983, judging the device a perpetual motion machine. Newman went to court.

The court appointed an expert, a former head of the patent office, who found Newman's evidence convincing. The judge, however, ordered a test at the National Bureau of Standards, today's NIST.

The Bureau studied the motor for several months. In June 1986 it announced: in every measurement the output power was lower than the power from the battery. The patent was not granted.

Newman still tried to convince senators. At the hearing, Senator John Glenn noted that his independent expert had had business dealings with him earlier. Newman's case is today an example in the patent office's manual.

How it was meant to work

  1. Huge coils: The motor had very large coils and a mechanical switch for reversing the current direction.
  2. Sparks when switching: Switching creates voltage spikes that are easy to measure wrongly and mistake for extra energy.
  3. Measurement: The Bureau of Standards measured the power drawn from the battery and the power delivered. Efficiency was always below 100%.

Investigation: facts and theories

Documented

Theories

What we don't know: Why the earlier measurements by supporters came out differently. The most common cause is faulty power measurement with voltage spikes.

Check for yourself

  1. The pendulum loses: Hang a key on a string and pull it back to a wall. Mark with a pencil where it returns after each swing. A little lower each time. The energy escapes to air resistance.
  2. An honest measurement: Wind up a spring-driven toy exactly 10 turns and measure how far it goes. Repeat 5 times. This is how inventions are tested: many measurements, the same conditions.
  3. Blind trial: Have someone hide a coin in one of three cups while you guess. Then swap, but the one hiding leaves the room before you guess. See how the hints from the face disappear. This is how an independent expert works.

What is known for certain

In 1986 the US National Bureau of Standards found no surplus of energy. The appeals court upheld the patent refusal (Newman v. Quigg, 1989). It is one of the few free-energy inventions that has really been properly examined.

Sources