Enter the forest
Antonio Meucci
Lost and forgotten inventors

Antonio Meucci

The telephone he could not afford to patent

◐ Under study

An Italian in New York connected his workshop to the bedroom of his sick wife by a wire so that they could talk. He could not afford a full patent.

Who: Antonio Meucci · When: 1856–1874 · Where: Staten Island, New York

See the illustrated storyphotos, animations and experiments to do yourself

The tale

Antonio Meucci was a theater technician in Florence and Havana. In 1850 he settled with his wife on Staten Island in New York. He hosted Giuseppe Garibaldi at his home.

Meucci's wife was seriously ill and could not get out of bed. Meucci connected her bedroom upstairs to his workshop with a device for transmitting voice, which he called the telettrofono.

Poverty did not let up. After a boiler explosion on a ferry Meucci was badly injured, and his wife sold his drawings and models to a junk dealer. In 1871 he filed only a so-called patent caveat, for 10 dollars. After 1874 he no longer renewed it.

In 1876 the patent for the telephone went to Alexander Graham Bell. Meucci fought in the courts until his death in 1889. In 2002 the U.S. House of Representatives passed a resolution recognizing his work on the telephone.

How it works

  1. A voice on a wire: A diaphragm vibrates with the voice and changes the current in the wire. At the other end the current moves a second diaphragm, which reproduces the sound.
  2. A caveat, not a patent: A patent caveat protected an idea for only a year and had to be renewed. A full patent cost far more.
  3. No description: The 1871 caveat contained no description of electromagnetic transmission of voice. That weakened his position in court.

Investigation: facts and theories

Documented

Theories

What we don't know: How exactly Meucci's first devices worked, since they were sold to a junk dealer. Whether his materials submitted to the telegraph company were lost by accident.

Check for yourself

  1. A cup telephone: Connect two yogurt cups with a taut string 10 meters long. Speak into one while someone listens with the other. The voice travels as vibrations.
  2. A slack string: Loosen the string and try again. You hear nothing. The vibrations need something to travel along.
  3. The diaphragm: Stretch cling film over a bowl and sprinkle rice on it. Shout close to the film. The rice jumps. This is how the diaphragm in a receiver vibrates.

What is known for certain

Meucci really did build devices for transmitting voice many years before Bell, as recognized, among others, by the 2002 resolution of the U.S. Congress and by the Italian authorities. Whether his apparatus worked like a true electromagnetic telephone remains disputed, because few documents have survived.

Sources