
Spires like antennas
Did cathedrals collect electricity from the sky?
☾ Unconfirmed
Tall spires, domes and metal finials were supposedly antennas that collected free energy from the atmosphere and distributed it to cities.
Who: The Tartary theory · When: Middle Ages–19th c. · Where: cathedrals and Orthodox churches
The tale
Look at a Gothic cathedral: sharp, tall spires, copper roofs, gilded crosses and orbs. According to the theory these are not decorations but devices.
The spire was supposed to catch electricity from the air, the dome to amplify it like a resonator, and the whole cathedral was a kind of power plant. It is also said that bells and organs worked at frequencies that healed.
Atmospheric electricity really does exist. The question is: how much of it is there, and can you live off it?
Theory versus historians
- Theory: The spires were antennas collecting energy from the atmosphere. Historians: On a clear day the voltage in the air is about 100 volts per metre of height, but the current is negligible: billionths of an ampere. It would not light even a single bulb.
- Theory: The builders had mastered electricity. Historians: Before Franklin invented the lightning rod in 1752, lightning regularly set churches on fire. Bell ringers rang the bells during storms to drive them away, and many were killed by strikes.
- Theory: Domes and gilding served as conductors. Historians: Gold and copper do not rust and they shine in the sun. Spires pointed to the sky and showed the wealth of the city. They were often built over entire centuries, which the chronicles describe well.
How it was meant to work
- The Earth's electric field: Between the ground and the ionosphere there is a voltage difference of about 250,000 volts. That is true, but air is a very poor conductor.
- Lightning rod: A metal rod at the top and a wire to the ground lead lightning safely past the building. It was invented by Benjamin Franklin.
- A home experiment: Rub a balloon on your hair and bring it close to a wall. There is charge, but hardly any energy. It is the same with the atmospheric field.
Check for yourself
- Old photos of the town: Find old photos of your town with towers and spires on fotopolska.eu and check which ones have survived.
- Where are the lightning rods: Take a look at a church tower nearby and look for a lightning rod. Ask how long it has been there.
What is known for certain
Atmospheric electricity is real, but it has too little power to supply a city. The history of lightning strikes and church fires shows that the builders of old could not control it. It is a beautiful legend, but without proof.